Beat Inflation: Make Your Own Flavored Coffee Syrups at Home

Beat Inflation: Make Your Own Flavored Coffee Syrups at Home

Posted by Jodie Dawson on

By Danielle Nemec

 

At home coffee is always a simple and more cost effective way of having coffee. All you need is your favorite (Java Love) coffee beans, milk/creamer, and some sort of coffee maker. But do you find yourself missing the rich and fun flavors of a local coffee shop’s craft lattes? Those artificial syrups can get expensive (not to mention some of the very unnatural ingredients they have). 

Here’s the good news: You can enjoy cafe-level flavors at home, without breaking the bank, just by making your own coffee syrups. It’s simple, customizable, and costs just a fraction of what you’d spend at the store or coffee shop. 


Here’s where to start:

Understand that all of these flavored syrups have a base of simple syrup (aka liquid sugar). So, to begin, you will need to start with this base syrup using the recipe below:

  • 1 cup sugar (about 50¢)

  • 1 cup water (pennies!)

  • Heat together in a small saucepan until the sugar dissolves completely.

  • Let cool and store in a clean jar or bottle.

This makes about 16 ounces of syrup for less than a dollar — compared to $10–$20 for a store-bought bottle.

Now, have some fun with it! Introduce a burst of flavor to these syrups using these simple additions below:

  • Vanilla: Stir in 1 teaspoon vanilla extract.

  • Cinnamon Brown Sugar: Add 2 teaspoons cinnamon + use brown sugar for a cozy flavor.

  • Maple Brown Sugar: ½ cup brown sugar + ½ cup maple syrup + ½ cup water

  • Honey Cinnamon: ½ cup honey + ½ cup water + 1 tsp ground cinnamon

  • Almond Vanilla: Mix in ½ teaspoon almond extract + a pinch of cocoa + ½ tsp vanilla extract

    Money Saving Tips:

    • Reuse glass bottles or mason jars instead of buying new containers.

    • Make small batches so nothing goes to waste.

    • Buy sugar in bulk — it’s cheaper per pound.

    For less than the cost of one fancy latte, you can whip up a whole batch of flavored syrup that lasts for weeks. It’s an easy way to keep your daily coffee ritual special, while keeping your wallet happy.

    So next time inflation has you debating whether to skip your favorite latte, grab a saucepan instead. Your homemade coffee bar is just a few ingredients away!

 

← Older Post Newer Post →

Blog

RSS
New Year, New Tea: Dry January, Hot Tea Month & A New Roast
2026 2026 drink trends alcohol-free lifestyle best drinks for Dry January Bolivian coffee beans caffeine alternatives to alcohol Caranavi Bolivia coffee coffee culture community-driven brands Dry January ethical sourcing healthy drink swaps after the holidays hot tea benefits in winter January wellness Java Love Java Love coffee Java Love Roastery Java Love tea medium roast coffee Bolivia mindful drinking National Hot Tea Month new coffee roast New Year resolutions 2026 New Year wellness drinks non-alcoholic beverages non-alcoholic winter drink ideas organic direct trade coffee Selva Verde Caranavi Selva Verde Caranavi coffee sustainable coffee tea benefits tea culture tea flavors for beginners tea vs alcohol in January warm drinks for cold weather wellness lifestyle winter warm drinks winter wellness routine

New Year, New Tea: Dry January, Hot Tea Month & A New Roast

By Jodie Dawson

Happy New Year! 2026 is here, and the crowd is… excited? Nervous? Or a secret third thing … tired. We’re only about two weeks into...

Read more
2025: Year in Review
barista life behind the scenes coffee best of essex coffee brand journey coffee business coffee business end of year coffee business growth story coffee community coffee milestones coffee roasting coffee shop blog coffee shop end of year recap coffee shop recap coffee shop year in review coffee table art book coffee trends customer appreciation end of year recap highlights from our coffee shop this year hot list Java Love local coffee shop Montclair New Jersey pride reflecting on a year in specialty coffee roastery small business small business growth specialty coffee specialty coffee highlights support local sustainable coffee Toni's Kitchen vintage pop up what we accomplished this year at our coffee shop year in review

2025: Year in Review

By Jodie Dawson

2025 has been a year of firsts, new collaborations and celebrating 14 years of Java Love! Before we take on 2026, grab your favorite mug...

Read more